Signs of a Toxic Boss: How Good People Can Succeed In the Executive Suite

by | Apr 28, 2022 | Corporate Culture, Leadership

I can’t tell you how many clients come to me with what they understand to be antithetical desires: executive success and authenticity. They’re very aware of the signs of a toxic boss and they don’t want to be that. They hope I can help them figure out how to be authentic, supportive of their team and successful at reaching the top even though they are not completely sure doing all that is even possible. 

Their uncertainty is surprising considering how many leadership books promote authenticity, collaboration (and the trust that results), as critical to every level of success—especially the top jobs. However, as we know, many leadership cultures tolerate and even support toxic leaders, so these concerns are not unfounded.

Photo by Brett Jordan

Signs of a Toxic Boss

Even more perplexing is that over the course of my career I’ve observed that many of the best people opt out of top roles, or the desire for them, because they believe the only way to get to the top is to do “whatever it takes” and exhibit signs of a toxic boss:

  • Self-centeredness somewhere on the narcissism scale
  • “Us-vs-Them” competitiveness 
  • Unrealistic expectations and impossible deadlines
  • Favoritism based on personal loyalty
  • Dictatorial decision making
  • Information hoarding
  • Emotionalism and reactivity
  • Lack of feedback or recognition
  • Unactionable negativity, criticism and belittling
  • Disinterest in others’ ideas
  • Blaming and shaming others
  • No accountability for themselves
  • Taking credit for others’ work
  • Unwillingness to consider ethical issues in decision making
  • Demanding 24 hour access to employees and face-time at the expense of personal productivity

When deciding whether to climb to the top, many believe that doing “whatever it takes” to get to the executive suite means becoming the kind of person they hate. Given this choice, opting out of the climb makes a lot of sense.

After observing many leaders, I believe that success at the top doesn’t mean doing “whatever it takes.” Instead, I believe it means, “never giving up.” Even in a culture that tolerates toxicity, there are authentic ways to succeed, and in doing so create opportunity for change. 

But to start this journey, we have to reimagine what it can look like for authenticity, healthy and collaborative managerial relationships, leadership and success to coexist at the executive level, where the pressure of survival (personally and for the business) can incentivize toxic behavior.

Keys to executive success: replace a “whatever it takes” mindset with a commitment to “never give up.” ⇐=Click to Tweet

Never Give Up: Rethinking the Executive’s Job

At its core, business is an inherently competitive game to access limited resources and produce profitable outcomes. While an abundance mindset in playing the game is healthy and breeds collaboration, at the end of the day customer and stakeholder resources are not unlimited.

It’s the job of the executive suite to set priorities, direct resources and make decisions that enable the organization to survive. The survival mandate of the top jobs too easily leads to an “ends justifies the means” mentality that makes it easy to excuse, allow and reward all the signs of a toxic boss: whatever it takes.

But the most inspiring, motivational and successful leaders are playing a different game, which is not just to survive but also to thrive. Instead of believing they can only succeed at productive ends or healthy means, they believe it’s possible to succeed by creating healthy ends and means. They recognize that this is a more challenging task and requires skill at balancing dynamics which are naturally and paradoxically in tension:

  • Competitive and cooperative mindsets
  • Relationship-building and task-focused activities
  • Big picture vision and detail oriented skills
  • Business success and personal wellness
  • Confident, visible and humble leadership
  • Empowering others and being accountable

This is difficult work and harder than simply surviving at any cost. At first the path forward can seem impossible, but the best leaders never give up in finding the way to “both/and” success. They play the game to win and bring as many people into the winning as they can, without allowing themselves to fall victim to exhibiting signs of a toxic boss. Specifically, what these leaders never do is be:

  • Unfocused/unprioritized
  • Emotionally reactive and triggered
  • Disrespectful of limitations
  • Negative and cynical

Accomplishing the Impossible

To some, succeeding in the “never give up, both/and” model described above seems either impossible or too exhausting, particularly if they work in an organization where the signs of a toxic boss run rampant. Burnout is a thing. It’s one thing to never give up and it’s another to bang your head against a wall that refuses to move. But somehow the best leaders find a way. They never give up looking for the right opportunity, somewhere, to lead authentically. And somehow, they always find it. 

Join us in the Women’s Mastermind to explore what “rethinking the executive suite” looks like for women in leadership.

Become a Master Influencer

Master the art of influence and persuasion with these simple tools you can use with bosses, customers, colleagues and friends.
Dana Theus

Dana Theus

Dana Theus is an executive coach specializing in helping you activate your highest potential to succeed and to shine. With her support emerging and established leaders, especially women, take powerful, high-road shortcuts to developing their authentic leadership style and discovering new levels of confidence and impact. Dana has worked for Fortune 50 companies, entrepreneurial tech startups, government and military agencies and non-profits and she has taught graduate-level courses for several Universities. learn more

Recent Posts

Can you get to the top without playing office politics?

Can you get to the top without playing office politics?

Office politics is as much a part of work as drawing a salary. And yet, I don’t know anyone who wants more of it. In fact, many clients come to me because they feel stymied in their career advancement goals because they perceive “office politics” to be getting in...

Career Coaching Tip: The Limits of Empathy

Career Coaching Tip: The Limits of Empathy

Early in my career, empathy was my ace-in-the-hole management technique. I was all business when it came to helping my team on technical, process and performance issues, but if they had an emotional reaction or issue, I reverted to empathy because it was the easy...

How To Get Through The Never Ending To-Do List

How To Get Through The Never Ending To-Do List

I’m a list maker. There’s something very gratifying for me to be able to cross things off my “list”. They’re done. Finished. It feels good and satisfying. I’m sure those of you who are list-makers can relate. But what about the task list that never ends? The one that...

Coaching Resources